Kia Soul Forums :: Kia Soul Owners banner

Non Car Savvy Soul Enthusiast looking for advice :)

176 Views 7 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  The Bishop of Graham
Hello everyone!

I lurked this community in past weeks because I was trying to gather information about Kia Souls. I used to have a 2005 Toyota Scion xb and man I loved that car. I eventually got a 2018 Hyundai Elantra Value Edition when I could afford a car payment and learned I loved the korean engineering!

I now find the Kia Soul's to be a merge between the comfiness, style, and quality that I had with both of my past cars!

I am very uninformed and I am struggling to pick a used model. I recently total'd my beautiful elantra (thank god I am safe!).

Some general questions (I will probably poke some of the other threads too)

How many miles would I be able to get out of one of these? Would it be safe to get one with 50k+ miles on it?

Im also curious if gen 1s, 2s, and 3s are that much of an improvement (or step back) from previous generations.

Lastly how do the newer generations hold value. I don't want to get a newer one if I can't recoup my losses when I eventually end up going to graduate school (don't want a car payment by then). I probably plan on selling this and getting a beater if I end up still having a car payment.

I will likely get $12-15k (likely lower end) from my insurance pay out and thus I do not want to get too deep into loans before next year. I would ideally like to have paid them off within the next year.

You all seem like very nice people so thanks for any insight :)

-Mikey
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
If you get 15k for your car your payment on a new Soul would be very little
  • Like
Reactions: 1
If you get 15k for your car your payment on a new Soul would be very little
Yeah, I am probably being paranoid, I guess I am still a bit bitter about being so close to paying my Elantra off that I don't want to nose dive straight into another several year loan. Its not really about the payment amount, but the fact my income may reduce substantially if I end up going back to school for my masters.

In the end it is probably not that big of a deal to be honest. What years would you say are the best to shoot for? Is the 2023 substantially different from other gen3s? Are gen 2s much worse than 3?

Thanks for your response!

-Mikey
Gen3 are much different than gen2 and the 2023 has even more updates styling wise as well as the instrument cluster etc.. With a used car it's like buying a scratch off lotto ticket, could be a winner or just a loser. There are ways to check it out but there is absolutely no way to know for sure how it was treated by previous owner. Maintenance records mean nothing as oil change places use tiny filters, don't replace crush washers etc... . With a few year old car you have the additional expense of replacing anything that is worn or might break and since your payment would be so little on a new one those little things might add up to more than your payment on a new one. Remember that a used one does not have the 10/100 warranty as that is for original owners only so you are on the hook for any repairs. There's also residual value that you can consider. Although depreciation is typically faster on a new car that has not been the case since Covid with 2-3 year old cars selling for around same price as new or I've often seen 1 year old cars advertised above what they cost new. Not sure that trend is sustainable but it is what it is. Get a new one and enjoy 100k of warrantied ownership or roll the dice on a used one.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
I'd try to find one a few years old with around 50,000 miles or so. DO NOT get the 1.6 engine. It might just be me, but I've read a lot more problems from owners with the 1.6 as opposed to the 2.0. My son has a 2016 with the 2.0 and about 68,000 miles on it. Zero problems with that car except for the sunroof making noise. I have a 2017 Forte with the 2.0 and have 142,000 miles on it and aside from regular maintenance, all I've had to do to it is replace a defective coil. Regardless of what year you choose, I highly recommend the 2.0 engine. Others here may agree or disagree and that's okay.
My 1.6L is just fine. 2.0L will fail if not maintained just as fast as a 1.6L.
Hello everyone!

I lurked this community in past weeks because I was trying to gather information about Kia Souls. I used to have a 2005 Toyota Scion xb and man I loved that car. I eventually got a 2018 Hyundai Elantra Value Edition when I could afford a car payment and learned I loved the korean engineering!

I now find the Kia Soul's to be a merge between the comfiness, style, and quality that I had with both of my past cars!

I am very uninformed and I am struggling to pick a used model. I recently total'd my beautiful elantra (thank god I am safe!).

Some general questions (I will probably poke some of the other threads too)

How many miles would I be able to get out of one of these? Would it be safe to get one with 50k+ miles on it?

Im also curious if gen 1s, 2s, and 3s are that much of an improvement (or step back) from previous generations.

Lastly how do the newer generations hold value. I don't want to get a newer one if I can't recoup my losses when I eventually end up going to graduate school (don't want a car payment by then). I probably plan on selling this and getting a beater if I end up still having a car payment.

I will likely get $12-15k (likely lower end) from my insurance pay out and thus I do not want to get too deep into loans before next year. I would ideally like to have paid them off within the next year.

You all seem like very nice people so thanks for any insight :)

-Mikey
Just don’t kick the FL Hamster.
Yeah, I am probably being paranoid, I guess I am still a bit bitter about being so close to paying my Elantra off that I don't want to nose dive straight into another several year loan. Its not really about the payment amount, but the fact my income may reduce substantially if I end up going back to school for my masters.

In the end it is probably not that big of a deal to be honest. What years would you say are the best to shoot for? Is the 2023 substantially different from other gen3s? Are gen 2s much worse than 3?

Thanks for your response!

-Mikey
Seriously though, someone I know bought his 2019 right after I got my 2020. The gen2 is a bit more comfy to drive. I like how the gen3 interior looks better.
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
Top